Your Nightmare Come To Life

"That shit hurts almost as much as blue balls"

"Oh please. I can't be as tight as Cal is." He murmured, letting out a gasp of a moan.

"you'd be surprised" Bro grinned.

"...Well shit, that's a compliment." Dave said with a light chuckle, followed by a low moan.

Bro slipped a third finger in.

"Mmmnnngh, fuck." He purred, starting to rock his hips into Bro's fingers.

"That's a boy" Bro hummed, spreading his fingers.

"Just for you." He groaned softly. "You and him."

"My good little boy" Bro smirked. "You think you're ready?"

Dave nodded, already panting ever so softly. "Always ready."

Bro pulled his fingers free and moved to line his cock up.

Dave slipped his legs around Bro's middle, giving him little urgent tugs.

"If you don't watch it, I won't be able to control myself" Bro smirked, pressing in slow.

Dave let out a shaky little sigh before giving him a soft amused huff. "Why wouldn't I want that?"

"I might hurt you" Bro stated.

"I told you I can take a little pain." Dave assured him, gripping the bed lightly as he felt himself filling up.

"A little?"

"A lottle." Dave  said as he wiggled a little, trying to get adjusted. "You should know I can take a lot, Bro."

"You should know I don't like hurting you"

"But I like it." Dave said with a soft pout. "It's not the bad kind of hurt. I promise. If you start to hurt me, I'll tell you."

Bro pressed in a little faster.

Dave's breathing hitched and he let out a moan, spreading his legs a little. "God, so big..." He whispered.

"You love it" Bro groaned

"Damn right I do." He mewled, clenching around the older male.

There was a chuckle from the doorway as Cal finally spoke up. "Can't leave you two alone for two seconds, can I?"

"You snooze" Jeff buried himself up to the hilt with a groan. "You loose"